Bitcoin and Ethereum ETF Approvals in the US: What Changed and What It Means for Investors

Bitcoin and Ethereum ETF Approvals in the US: What Changed and What It Means for Investors

Ethereum ETF Yield Calculator

Calculate Ethereum ETF Returns

Enter your investment amount to see potential returns

For over a decade, investors waited for the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) to say yes to a spot Bitcoin ETF. The answer didn’t come until January 10, 2024 - and then, six months later, the same thing happened with Ethereum. These weren’t just product launches. They were regulatory turning points that pulled cryptocurrency out of the shadows and into the mainstream financial system.

Why the SEC Took So Long

The SEC rejected 13 Bitcoin ETF applications between 2013 and 2023. Each time, they cited concerns about market manipulation, lack of custody, and the volatile nature of crypto. But in August 2023, a federal court ruled that the SEC had been inconsistent - approving Bitcoin futures ETFs while blocking spot ones, even though both tracked the same asset. That decision forced the SEC’s hand. By January 2024, they approved the first spot Bitcoin ETFs, including BlackRock’s IBIT and Fidelity’s FBTC. The market didn’t just react - it exploded. IBIT hit $4.6 billion in assets within its first week.

What Spot ETFs Actually Are

A spot ETF lets you buy shares that directly track the price of Bitcoin or Ethereum held in secure custody. Unlike futures ETFs, which bet on future prices, spot ETFs are tied to the real-time value of the coin. You don’t need a crypto wallet. You don’t need to worry about private keys. You just buy the ETF like you’d buy Apple or Tesla stock. The ETF provider holds the actual Bitcoin or Ether, and your shares represent a claim on that asset.

The Big Shift: In-Kind Creation (July 2025)

The first Bitcoin and Ethereum ETFs used a cash-only model. To create new shares, authorized participants had to buy Bitcoin or Ether on the open market and sell it for cash to fund the ETF. That created tax events, extra fees, and price distortions. It also made it hard for big holders - the so-called “whales” - to move their holdings into ETFs without selling.

That changed on July 29, 2025, when the SEC approved in-kind creation and redemption. Now, institutions can swap actual Bitcoin or Ether directly for ETF shares - no cash needed. This is how gold ETFs like GLD have worked for 20 years. It’s cleaner, cheaper, and more efficient.

By October 2025, BlackRock had processed over $3 billion in in-kind conversions. Bitwise and Galaxy Digital saw 47% and 63% quarter-over-quarter growth in client requests for this feature. The SEC estimated this change would save the crypto ETF market $150-250 million per year in operational costs. For big holders, it meant they could now move their crypto into a regulated, liquid vehicle without triggering capital gains taxes.

Two cute ETF tokens exchanging crypto coins in a glowing in-kind transfer

Bitcoin vs. Ethereum ETFs: Key Differences

While both are spot ETFs, they’re not the same. Bitcoin runs on proof-of-work. Ethereum runs on proof-of-stake. That small technical difference created big market consequences.

Bitcoin ETFs all have identical structures: hold Bitcoin, no staking, no rewards. Simple. Transparent. Low risk.

Ethereum ETFs? More complex. Since Ethereum generates staking rewards (currently around 3.5% annual yield), ETF providers had to decide: do we keep the rewards or pass them to investors? Only five of the 11 approved Ethereum ETFs chose to stake. Grayscale’s ETHE, for example, allocated 4.2% of its 3.1 million ETH holdings to staking - generating $127 million in quarterly rewards distributed to shareholders. Other providers, like VanEck’s EETH, chose not to stake at all, keeping things simpler.

Fees reflect this complexity. Bitcoin ETFs average 0.25% in management fees. Fidelity’s FBTC charges 0.00%. Grayscale’s GBTC still charges 0.90% - a legacy of its old trust structure. Ethereum ETFs? They average 0.35%. Grayscale’s ETHE charges 1.50%, the highest in the market. Investors are voting with their wallets: VanEck’s EETH, with its 0.15% fee, quickly became the second-largest Ethereum ETF by AUM.

Market Performance and Investor Behavior

As of September 2025, spot Bitcoin ETFs held $54.3 billion in assets. BlackRock’s IBIT led with $16.9 billion - over 30% of the total. Ethereum ETFs totaled $18.7 billion, with Grayscale’s ETHE leading at $5.1 billion.

But the trends tell a more interesting story. In Q3 2025, Bitcoin ETFs saw $1.2 billion in net outflows. Ethereum ETFs saw $478 million in inflows. Why? Because Ethereum’s staking rewards offered yield in a high-interest-rate environment. Investors weren’t just buying crypto - they were buying income.

Institutional behavior changed, too. A survey of 142 institutional investors found that 78% now prefer holding Bitcoin through ETFs for easier collateralization in prime brokerage deals. Reddit users praised the “regulatory clarity” but slammed Grayscale’s fees. Trustpilot reviews of Coinbase’s ETF integration showed 72% of users loved the ease of moving from self-custody to ETF exposure - but 28% struggled with the tax paperwork for in-kind conversions.

Financial street with Bitcoin and Ethereum ETF stalls, customers choosing low-fee options

Global Ripple Effects

The U.S. didn’t act alone. In October 2025, the Hong Kong Stock Exchange launched its first spot Solana ETF - charging 0.99% annual fees. The UK’s Financial Conduct Authority lifted its four-year ban on crypto ETNs, letting firms like 21Shares and Bitwise offer physical Bitcoin and Ether products inside UK ISAs. These moves weren’t coincidental. They were responses to the U.S. approval. When Wall Street opens the door, global markets follow.

What’s Next?

The SEC’s October 2025 orders didn’t just approve in-kind processing for Bitcoin and Ethereum. They said it applied to “a host of crypto asset ETPs.” That’s a green light for more. Evernorth’s $1 billion deal to acquire XRP for yield strategies hints at a possible XRP ETF. Solana’s ETF in Hong Kong is just the start - Singapore and the EU are expected to launch similar products by mid-2026.

But the SEC isn’t opening the floodgates. Chairman Paul S. Atkins said clearly: “Not all crypto assets will qualify for ETP treatment under our framework.” That means each new asset - Cardano, Polkadot, Chainlink - will face its own review. The bar is higher now. You need strong custody, transparent pricing, and clear legal standing.

What This Means for You

If you’re an investor, the approval of Bitcoin and Ethereum ETFs means you can now access crypto through your brokerage account - no crypto exchange needed. You get the same tax treatment as stocks. You get daily liquidity. You get institutional-grade custody.

But you still need to be smart. Fees matter. Grayscale’s 1.50% fee on ETHE eats into returns. Staking rewards aren’t guaranteed - they depend on Ethereum’s network performance. And while ETFs reduce custody risk, they don’t eliminate market risk. Bitcoin and Ethereum can still crash.

The real win? Regulatory clarity. For the first time, the SEC has created a path for crypto to exist within the same legal framework as stocks, bonds, and gold. That’s not just a product change. It’s a cultural shift.

Are Bitcoin and Ethereum ETFs the same as buying crypto directly?

No. When you buy a Bitcoin or Ethereum ETF, you own shares in a fund that holds the actual coins. You don’t hold the private keys. You can’t send the crypto to a wallet. You trade it like a stock. It’s more convenient and regulated, but you lose direct control. If you want full ownership - like sending ETH to a DeFi protocol - you still need to buy it on an exchange.

Why do some Ethereum ETFs pay staking rewards and others don’t?

It’s a choice made by each ETF provider. Staking Ethereum generates rewards (around 3.5% per year), but it adds complexity. Providers like Grayscale chose to stake to offer yield, while others like VanEck kept it simple to avoid operational risk. If you want passive income from your Ethereum ETF, check the fund’s prospectus to see if it stakes and how often rewards are distributed.

Are Bitcoin ETFs safer than Ethereum ETFs?

Not necessarily. Both are spot ETFs with strong custody. But Ethereum ETFs have extra risk because they involve staking - which depends on the Ethereum network’s security. If staking were compromised, rewards could stop or be slashed. Bitcoin has no such mechanism. Its only risk is price volatility. So if you want simplicity and predictability, Bitcoin ETFs are safer. If you want yield and are okay with more complexity, Ethereum ETFs offer more.

Can I use my IRA or 401(k) to invest in these ETFs?

Yes. Since these are SEC-approved ETFs traded on major exchanges, they’re eligible for retirement accounts. Many brokerage platforms like Fidelity, Charles Schwab, and Vanguard now let you buy Bitcoin and Ethereum ETFs inside IRAs and 401(k)s. That’s a big deal - it means crypto is now part of mainstream retirement planning.

Will more crypto ETFs get approved?

Almost certainly. The SEC’s July and October 2025 rulings opened the door for “a host of crypto asset ETPs.” Solana’s ETF in Hong Kong is already live. Analysts expect XRP, Cardano, and Chainlink ETFs to follow, but each will need to meet the same standards: clear custody, transparent pricing, and no regulatory red flags. The SEC isn’t approving everything - just the ones that fit their new framework.

Do I pay taxes when I buy a Bitcoin ETF?

You don’t pay taxes just for buying the ETF. But if you sell it for a profit, you’ll owe capital gains tax - just like with stocks. The big change in 2025 was in-kind conversions: if you transfer Bitcoin directly into an ETF (instead of selling it for cash), you don’t trigger a taxable event. That’s huge for long-term holders. But if you sell Bitcoin to buy the ETF with cash, you owe taxes on the gain. Always check with a tax professional.

25 Comments

  • Image placeholder

    sky 168

    November 21, 2025 AT 09:41

    Finally, crypto is getting treated like real assets. No more sketchy exchanges. Just buy it like Apple stock. Game changer.

  • Image placeholder

    Devon Bishop

    November 22, 2025 AT 17:18

    man i still dont get why graysclae charges 0.9% when everyone else is under 0.3%… like bro its 2025 not 2018

  • Image placeholder

    sammy su

    November 24, 2025 AT 09:03

    if you’re holding bitcoin in an etf you’re not really owning it. you’re owning a piece of paper that says you own it. still better than keeping keys on your phone tho.

  • Image placeholder

    jack leon

    November 25, 2025 AT 19:52

    THEY DID IT. THE WALL STREET MACHINE JUST ATE CRYPTO AND SPIT IT OUT AS A MUTUAL FUND. I’M NOT SURE IF I’M THRILLED OR SICK TO MY STOMACH. THIS IS THE END OF THE ORIGINAL VISION.

  • Image placeholder

    Chris G

    November 27, 2025 AT 14:50

    in kind creation was the only logical move. anyone who thought cash only was sustainable was delusional

  • Image placeholder

    Phil Taylor

    November 28, 2025 AT 21:28

    the us is just turning crypto into a bank product so they can tax it better. this isnt progress its assimilation.

  • Image placeholder

    diljit singh

    November 30, 2025 AT 09:51

    why are people so excited about etfs when you can just buy btc on binance for free

  • Image placeholder

    Abhishek Anand

    December 1, 2025 AT 19:48

    the real question is not whether etfs are good but whether the sec has the authority to define what money is. we are entering a new constitutional era

  • Image placeholder

    vinay kumar

    December 2, 2025 AT 15:16

    staking rewards are a scam. ether is not a bond. dont confuse yield with value

  • Image placeholder

    Lara Ross

    December 3, 2025 AT 07:36

    This is the moment we’ve been waiting for. Institutional adoption doesn’t mean the end of decentralization-it means the beginning of legitimacy. You can still hodl your keys, but now you have a safe, regulated way to participate without risking your life savings on an exchange that might vanish tomorrow. This isn’t just about money. It’s about security. It’s about trust. And it’s about time.

  • Image placeholder

    Leisa Mason

    December 3, 2025 AT 14:33

    1.5% fee on ethe? thats a joke. grayscales just monetizing their monopoly. anyone buying that is either naive or already rich enough not to care

  • Image placeholder

    Rob Sutherland

    December 5, 2025 AT 02:06

    we used to think crypto was about freedom. now its about custody agreements and prospectuses. i dont know if that’s progress or surrender.

  • Image placeholder

    Tim Lynch

    December 6, 2025 AT 07:14

    the sec didn’t approve crypto. they approved the financialization of crypto. there’s a difference. one is liberation. the other is absorption.

  • Image placeholder

    Melina Lane

    December 6, 2025 AT 21:22

    so happy to see my dad finally invest in btc through his 401k. he said he didn’t understand crypto but now he can just click a button. that’s the real win.

  • Image placeholder

    Peter Mendola

    December 7, 2025 AT 19:31

    Bitcoin ETF AUM: $54.3B. Ethereum ETF AUM: $18.7B. Fee differentials: 0.25% vs 0.35%. Staking yield: 3.5%. In-kind conversion volume: $3B+. Tax efficiency: confirmed. Market structure: normalized.

  • Image placeholder

    Terry Watson

    December 9, 2025 AT 18:05

    so… if i swap my 10 btc for ibit shares… no taxes? but if i sell my btc for cash and then buy ibit… i owe capital gains? that’s insane. the system is rigged to reward the rich who already hold crypto. how is that fair?

  • Image placeholder

    Dexter Guarujá

    December 11, 2025 AT 00:54

    the us is the only country that can turn a revolution into a mutual fund. we turned freedom into a 401k. congratulations america

  • Image placeholder

    taliyah trice

    December 12, 2025 AT 07:02

    my grandma just bought fbtc through chase. she called it 'the digital gold fund'. i cried a little.

  • Image placeholder

    Charan Kumar

    December 12, 2025 AT 11:01

    india will never allow this. we still cant buy crypto on our banks. usa is so far ahead

  • Image placeholder

    andrew casey

    December 13, 2025 AT 00:31

    The regulatory architecture established by the SEC in Q3 2025 represents a paradigmatic shift in asset classification. The conflation of custody mechanisms with fiduciary obligations under ERISA and the Investment Company Act of 1940 has effectively created a new asset class: regulated digital commodity-backed securities. This is not merely an ETF approval-it is the codification of digital scarcity into the U.S. capital markets framework.

  • Image placeholder

    Roshan Varghese

    December 15, 2025 AT 00:14

    theyre gonna put cardano etf next and then the fed will start buying it as collateral… this is how they take over crypto… its all a trap

  • Image placeholder

    Norm Waldon

    December 15, 2025 AT 06:10

    THEY LET THEM IN. THE GOVERNMENT LET THEM IN. NOW THEY’LL TAX YOU FOR EVERY TIME YOU TRADE. THEY’LL TRACK YOUR WALLET THROUGH THE ETF PROVIDER. THEY’LL REQUIRE KYC ON YOUR RETIREMENT ACCOUNT. THIS ISN’T FREEDOM-IT’S A SURVEILLANCE PROGRAM WITH A 0.25% FEE.

  • Image placeholder

    Sunita Garasiya

    December 15, 2025 AT 06:39

    so let me get this straight… we spent 10 years fighting for decentralization, and now the answer is… we let the banks hold our keys and call it 'regulated'? brilliant. the revolution was always going to be sold as a subscription service.

  • Image placeholder

    Khalil Nooh

    December 15, 2025 AT 15:57

    LOOK. I DON’T CARE IF IT’S A MUTUAL FUND OR A WALLET. IF I CAN PUT BTC IN MY IRA AND MY KID CAN LEARN ABOUT MONEY WITHOUT BEING SCAMMED ON COINBASE-THEN THIS IS A WIN. STOP OVER-THINKING IT. THE PEOPLE WON.

  • Image placeholder

    sky 168

    December 16, 2025 AT 04:37

    Just bought my first Ethereum ETF today. The staking rewards are like free interest. It’s not perfect, but it’s the closest thing to passive crypto income without running a node.

Write a comment